As I watched Luton Town get literally torpedoed out of the football league by both the FA and the FL this week with their 30 point deduction being upheld, and as I watched the papers churn out yet more club-via-agent drivel designed to unsettle the contracted staff of other teams, I found my mind drifting to motorway caffs and brown paper bags. Remember those days? A jag would pull up at the Watford Gap services, a couple of geezers in long overcoats with collars out would shuffle inside, and as the lukewarm sausage, beans and chips took on a rubbery layer of grease, the old crinkled brown paper bag would find it’s way next to the rolled up copy of The Evening Standard and PRESTO! The next afternoon, a major transfer was born, supporters were delighted, neither chairman seemed to be complaining and none of the other parties involved were unhappy. Indeed, everyone was cheery, no-one was complaining and things moved on smoothly (partially because no-one was stupid enough to actually eat the sausage, beans and chips!).
Oh the rumors flew around from time to time, but transfer windows were more civilized, managers operated under a code of conduct, and the various officiating bodies did a decent job of turning blind eyes to obvious problems. Only George Graham and Brian Clough ever really got dragged through the mud, and in the former’s case, you could say that greed played a major part (as for Cloughie? I’ll never be convinced it wasn’t a bottle of scotch in ‘that’ particular brown paper bag!).
But then, one fateful day, the officiating bodies got a bad idea. Imagine a world with NO bungs, they pondered, NO dodgy agents, NO illicit payments and NO tapping up. Unilaterally. A world where everyone, as best could be administered, was equal. It seemed like a brave new era. And the only reason the idea was bad, was because none of them could organize a piss-up in a brewery, let alone the complexities of this irritating issue.
Err, I’ll have a ham and cheese plus one Teddy please…
The FA hired a ‘bung-buster’, Graham Bean, back in 1998. Mr.Bean (and I use the term in full knowledge of the image it brings to mind) gave up 17 years in the police force to take the job. He was to ferret out the bad people and clean it all up. He was to be a Knight in shining armor. He was to head up a ‘compliance’ team. Oh how sweet it sounded. By 2003, he was being offered a pay-off to leave his post. He had become disillusioned with the lack of support he felt he was receiving from his superiors, and as he walked out the door, so did a fair few of his dossiers on figures within the game such as John Gregory and the agency Proactive and it’s chief executive Paul Stretford.
Recently we saw some spluttered rumblings of action as the great bung inquiries looked set to ensnare Harry Redknapp, agent Willie McKay and Sam Allardyce. There was even an edition of UK news program Panorama which appeared to supply some pretty irrefutable evidence against both Redknapp and Allardyce. And what did it all come to? Nothing. Absolutely nothing.
Just like the 2006 scandal involving Arsenal and their manager Arsene Wenger. British TV show Newsnight blew the lid off the fashion in which Wenger had basically set up a ‘football factory’ which would see Ivorian youth players signed by Belgian club Beveren, where Arsenal would then swoop for them if deemed good enough. A former colleague of Wenger’s, Jean-Marc Gillou, had an academy for young players in Abidjan. he was also the guiding force behind who Beveren signed. Newsnight claimed that any profits made via player sales by Beveren would result in 30% of said-fee being given to Gillou (at this point I should point out that Emmanuel Eboue was bought from Beveren by Arsenal for an ‘undisclosed figure.’ Throw in the fact that a spell in Belgium helps work permit situations and the math could not be clearer. Add to this the fact that Arsenal made a 1 million pound ‘unamed’ loan to Beveren, and you can see the plot is pretty thick and requires some deeper investigation…unless you’re the FA, the Premier League of FIFA, all of whom found ways to distance themselves from the blaring accusations raised by the Newsnight story.
Instead, football seems to prefer to see clubs like Luton Town battered from pillar to post for the indiscretions of past regimes. Not content with punishing small clubs like Luton, who already find it hard to jostle for any elbow room in the increasingly rarefied circles of British football, these absolute paragons of hypocrisy wish to beat the dream of ‘examples’….they’re setting an example, they’re creating a precedent.
But are they? I wonder what Sheffield United would have to say about these morons and their ‘precedents’. I wonder how anyone can view the insanely arbitrary ‘punishment’ handed out to West Ham for their illegal registration of Carlos Tevez and Javier Mascherano. Indeed, on April 27th, the Hammers were fined 5.5 million pounds for witholding information on who owned the players (MSI – a group of international investors owned the players). Curiously, there was no immediate stipulation banning Tevez from appearing again in West Ham colors until the matter was sorted out, and there was even more curiously no points deduction. This despite two illegally registered players having appeared in a number of matches. This despite the fact that one of those players was the only reason West Ham avoided relegation in the first place.
On May 13th, 2007, in a match West Ham had to win to avoid relegation, Carlos Tevez scored the winning goal at Old Trafford. Against Man Utd. The club he would go on to join for the start of the following season. Sheffield United were relegated instead. West ham, with their multi-millionaire owners, paid the fine whilst laughing no doubt. Sheffield United, without nearly the same level of financial clout, had to recruit resources to take their case to an appeal. Which, of course, failed (the appeal that is).
So perhaps NOW my cry for to BRING BACK THE BUNG makes more sense. It was so much easier when people didn’t pretend they cared about the sanctity of the game. it was so much better when we didn’t have to witness such flagrant abuses of power. It was so much more fun when the back-pages weren’t taken up by the sort of hypocritical sanctimonious waffle from the Premiership, the Football League and the FA explaining to us how beating the likes of Luton Town to near-death with billy clubs is going to save football.
My advice to all those morons who are spouting this obscenely hypocritical rubbish is to do us a favor and don’t even try to justify the disparity. Just quietly acknowledge that there is one rule for one and another rule for others, and the whole thing depends on exactly what sort of clout you carry in the game. This would also allow the likes of Luton Town to understand that honesty is not the right path, that in fact it’s better for them to shut up and sort it out internally. Anything else is, these days, an egregious insult to all genuine football supporters.




